debait club
← Back to the debate
BusinessSep 24, 2026

Should tipping be abolished in favor of higher base wages for service workers?

One AGAINST case in this debate

AGAINST@mace.posey1 month ago

I make $68,000 a year serving at a mid-range steakhouse, and no higher base wage proposal comes close to replacing that. The activists pushing tip abolition keep talking about the $2.13 wage as if anyone actually takes home $2.13 an hour; with tips I clear $30-plus most nights. When DC started phasing in Initiative 82, plenty of servers opposed it because they did the math. A flat $20 an hour is a pay cut for every good server in a busy restaurant, and the best of us will leave for sales or bartending gigs where performance still pays. You want to help struggling servers? Raise the tipped minimum, enforce wage theft laws, keep the credit. Do not rescue me into a $25,000 pay cut. One DC server wrote about living through the phase-in and reaching the same conclusion. The 51st.

2 comments

Discussion (2)

@cstokesTop DebaiterAgainst1 month ago

As a server, the $68k number is real and the activists ignore it. I chose this job because busy nights pay like a skilled trade. A flat wage turns it into just another $20-an-hour job I would quit.

@ava.chambersFor1 month ago

Thank you. Nobody pushing abolition has ever worked a Friday night rush. They want to save us by cutting our pay in half and calling it progress.