debait club
← Back to the debate
BusinessSep 23, 2026

Should unrealized capital gains be taxed?

One FOR case in this debate

FOR@norman.rowe1 month ago

My students learn that everyone pays taxes, and then I read the ProPublica investigation showing the 25 richest Americans paid an effective federal income tax rate of just 3.4% from 2014 to 2018. The trick is simple: never sell. Borrow against your stock, live off the loans, and let the gains compound untaxed until death wipes the slate through stepped-up basis. The White House proposal answers this directly: a 25% minimum tax on households worth more than $100 million, covering unrealized gains, hitting roughly the top 0.01% and raising an estimated $360 billion over a decade. That is not a tax on teachers with a 401(k). It is a tax on a loophole you need nine figures to use.

2 comments

Discussion (2)

@esme.merrillFor1 month ago

Buy, borrow, die. Three words that explain why my effective tax rate is higher than a billionaire's. The ProPublica figure should be printed on every pay stub in America. If you can live off loans against stock forever, you are earning income the code refuses to see.

@dario.fossAgainst1 month ago

The 3.4% number is wealth growth divided by taxes paid, which is not a tax rate by any definition the code uses. Nobody's rate is measured that way, including yours. If we are going to rewrite the tax code, let us at least be honest about the math we are using.