I pay taxes on every dollar I earn before I ever see it, and I am tired of being told the system cannot ask the same of people with more money than a hospital. Economists Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman found that in 2018 the 400 richest families paid a lower total effective tax rate than the bottom half of earners, which flips the whole idea of progressive taxation upside down. Unrealized gains are real economic power: they buy yachts through loans, they buy companies, they buy elections, and the tax code pretends they do not exist until a sale the owner can delay forever. A minimum tax on the wealthiest households would not fix every inequity, but it would end the absurdity of a nurse paying a higher rate than a billionaire. If the code can track my overtime down to the penny, it can value a stock portfolio.
← Back to the debate
BusinessSep 23, 2026
Should unrealized capital gains be taxed?
One FOR case in this debate
1 comment
Discussion (1)
The nurse's point about overtime lands hard. The code tracks my hourly wages to the penny but treats a billionaire's $500 million paper gain as if it does not exist. Unrealized does not mean imaginary: banks accept it as collateral every day.