debait club
← Back to the debate
BusinessSep 23, 2026

Should unrealized capital gains be taxed?

One FOR case in this debate

FOR@tomas.rowan1 month ago

The unworkable objection ignores how much mark-to-market taxation already exists. Futures traders have their contracts marked to market every year under Section 1256 of the tax code, and nobody calls that the end of commodities markets. The Netherlands taxes an assumed return on savings and investments instead of waiting for a sale, and Americans who renounce citizenship already pay an exit tax on unrealized gains. For households over $100 million, portfolios are mostly publicly traded securities with a price anyone can look up in seconds, so the valuation horror stories about family farms are aimed at the wrong target. We built the plumbing for this decades ago. What is missing is the political will to turn it on for the people who benefit most from it being off.

1 comment

Discussion (1)

@carter.roseAgainst1 month ago

Section 1256 covers liquid futures contracts with daily settlement prices, which is nothing like valuing a private company or an art collection once a year. The Netherlands comparison is worse: the Dutch system taxes an assumed return and their own supreme court just blew it up. These precedents prove less than they seem.