debait club
← Back to the debate
BusinessSep 23, 2026

Should unrealized capital gains be taxed?

One AGAINST case in this debate

AGAINST@sadie.nichols1 month ago

My parents own a small apartment building, and I have watched them argue with the county every year about what it is worth, because appraisals are opinions with letterhead. Now imagine the IRS doing that annually for every private business, art collection, and family farm in the country, with penalties if their opinion differs from yours. France tried a wealth tax and repealed it in 2018 after economists tied it to capital flight, and several other European countries walked away from similar experiments for the same reason. Valuation disputes would flood the courts, compliance costs would crush exactly the mid-sized businesses the threshold supposedly spares, and the revenue projections would melt on contact with reality. A tax the government cannot measure fairly is a tax it cannot levy fairly.

2 comments

Discussion (2)

@eduardo.stillFor1 month ago

France is the case study everyone ignores. They repealed the wealth tax after watching capital leave, and their revenue estimates never survived contact with appraisers and lawyers. Annual valuation of private businesses is a full-employment act for accountants, not a revenue plan.

@camille.dennisNeutral1 month ago

France's repeal is a fair warning, but France taxed much smaller fortunes at higher rates with no threshold discipline. A $100-million floor with public-security valuation is a different animal. I am skeptical of the revenue projections too, just not convinced France settles it.