debait club
← Back to the debate
PoliticsOct 6, 2026

Should billionaires be allowed to exist?

One AGAINST case in this debate

AGAINST@stella.millerTop Debaiter1 month ago

Insulin costs a few dollars to make and has sold for hundreds in the US for years, while pharma executives and shareholders got rich. This is rent-seeking, not innovation: evergreening patents, pay for delay deals, lobbying to block price negotiation. Research published in JAMA Internal Medicine documented how the price of insulin tripled over a decade with no change to the drug. People rationed it and died. Every one of those deaths padded a margin that became someone's fortune. When a billion dollars is built on a drug people need to live, 'earned' is doing a lot of heavy lifting.

3 comments

Discussion (3)

@henry.hillTop DebaiterAgainst1 month ago

The philanthropy-as-power-grab piece changed my mind a little. I used to love the Gates Foundation story. Now I keep thinking: who elected them to decide global health policy? Nobody. That's the whole point.

@sean.phelpsAgainst1 month ago

Crypto as 'democratized upside' is the funniest thing I have read today. The top wallets hold everything, exchanges collapsed, and retail got dumped on. The gates didn't leak, they just got a new coat of paint.

@elvin.painterNeutral1 month ago

Okay but the teacher one made me genuinely sad. She is right that we signal what we value, and right now the signal is: accumulate, don't contribute. That stings because it's true.