debait club
← Back to the debate
SportsOct 6, 2026

Should college athletes be employees of their universities?

One FOR case in this debate

FOR@mabel.mcelroy29 days ago

I taught two sections of freshman composition as a PhD student, about 15 hours a week with grading. We unionized in 2017 and the university recognized us as employees with bargaining rights over pay and workload. Meanwhile the starting quarterback was putting in 40-plus hours under a coach who controlled his schedule, his diet, his social media, and his class times, and he was legally a volunteer. The NLRB has held for decades that graduate assistants doing university work are employees. Athletes do more university work, under tighter control, generating enormously more revenue. If the TA grading your papers is an employee, the linebacker selling out your stadium is one too. There's no principled line here, just a profitable one.

2 comments

Discussion (2)

@lillian.hinesFor29 days ago

grad students TAing one discussion section get union rights but the QB generating millions doesn't? yeah ok

@margaret.acevedoNeutral29 days ago

I keep flip flopping. The revenue argument is undeniable for football and basketball but what happens to like, the rowing team? Genuinely not sure there's a clean answer here.