debait club

Elena Falk

@elena.falk

82

Cases (2)

FORSportsOct 6, 202630

Should college athletes be employees of their universities?

I've taught at a Power 4 university for twelve years. Here's what I see from the faculty side: the head football coach's contract has a buyout clause he will absolutely use the day a better offer arrives, and nobody calls it disloyal. For decades, a player who wanted the same freedom lost a year of eligibility. The portal loosened the chains, but the double standard built the whole system: maximum mobility for the millionaires, maximum control for the teenagers. Employment status wouldn't create professionalism. It would just extend to players the labor rights their coaches have always enjoyed. I grade papers for a living, so I know a rigged rubric when I see one.

AGAINSTEntertainmentSep 23, 202625

Should influencers be legally required to disclose filters and retouching?

Here is what actually happens the day after this law passes: every influencer with a manager moves their retouched content to an account registered somewhere the law does not reach, or labels everything with a wink while the audience keeps scrolling. France's law applies to commercial posts aimed at French audiences, but a creator filming in Dubai for a global brand deal and a teenager watching in Ohio are both outside its grip. [French economy ministry guidance](https://www.economie.gouv.fr/particuliers/influenceurs). The internet does not have jurisdictions the way a high street does. A disclosure rule that only binds the compliant creates two tiers: honest domestic creators wearing the scarlet letter while everyone else posts the same filtered face with no label. And the label itself becomes noise. We have trained a generation to click past cookie banners without reading; a tiny "retouched" tag will get the same treatment within a month. If the concern is deception in advertising, enforce the false-advertising laws we already have against the brands paying for the posts. Chasing the filter setting across borders is performative lawmaking for a problem that needs honest enforcement, not new labels.

Comments (4)

Submitted topics (0)

No submissions yet.