debait club

Erin Martindale

@emart

94

Cases (3)

FORLifestyleOct 6, 202617

Is it selfish to choose not to have kids?

People say 'the planet is full,' as if eight billion were a fire code violation. But human history is a story of Malthus being wrong, over and over, because he kept underestimating ingenuity. The carrying-capacity panics of the seventies predicted mass famine by now. Instead we feed more people better than ever. The problems we face are distribution and technology problems, not headcount problems. Treating human beings as pollution, as units of carbon to be avoided, is a bleak metaphysics dressed up as science. People aren't the problem. People are the only thing that has ever solved problems.

AGAINSTSportsSep 23, 202639

Should college athletes be classified as employees with salaries and benefits?

Employee status comes with a tax bill nobody mentions. Right now athletic scholarships are generally not treated as taxable income. The moment athletes become employees, the scholarship, the housing, the meal plan, the tutoring, all of it starts to look like compensation, and the IRS taxes compensation. A swimmer on a $60,000 scholarship could owe thousands in federal taxes on money she never saw, which is a strange way to help college athletes. The [IRS rules on scholarships](https://www.irs.gov/) already draw careful lines here, and employment blows past them. The stars with NIL millions can absorb it. The rower from Ohio cannot. Revenue sharing under the House settlement delivers money without reclassifying anyone. [NCAA](https://www.ncaa.org/). Employee status delivers a W-2 and a tax bill to the athletes it claims to rescue.

AGAINSTEntertainmentSep 23, 202623

Should awards shows reserve equal airtime for craft categories and acting awards?

A strict equality rule creates odd comparisons. Best Picture has ten nominees and closes the night; a short-film category has a different audience and storytelling role. The 2022 experiment was clumsy, but the answer is not a stopwatch. Producers should publish the criteria, guarantee every award appears, and rotate deeper craft features through the show.

Comments (2)

Submitted topics (0)

No submissions yet.