debait club

JavierTop Debaiter

@javier

Top Debaiter · in the top 50

225

Cases (4)

FOREntertainmentOct 6, 202626

Are movie theaters dead, or is the big screen irreplaceable?

I have a four-year-old and a one-year-old, so my last trip to a theater cost $74 before I bought a single popcorn, and my daughter melted down twenty minutes into a movie she had begged to see. At home I can pause for the bathroom, rewind the part I missed while making bottles, and turn on subtitles because half the dialogue is mumbled anyway. Nobody is arguing the couch beats a 70-foot screen. The argument is that the theater experience was designed for people whose lives allow a three-hour uninterrupted block, and most adults with jobs and kids simply don't have those anymore. The industry keeps marketing to a lifestyle that's shrinking.

AGAINSTPoliticsOct 6, 202624

Should billionaires be allowed to exist?

Stock buybacks used to be illegal market manipulation. Now they're the main engine of billionaire wealth. Companies borrow money to buy their own shares, the stock pops, execs cash out, and workers get layoffs. The Economic Policy Institute tracked how buybacks exploded after the 2017 tax cuts while wages barely moved: [EPI on buybacks](https://www.epi.org/). It's financialization in one chart. The fortune gets built by shrinking the share count, not by making better products. If we want fewer billionaires, I'd start by making buybacks manipulation again.

AGAINSTBusinessSep 23, 20268

Should privacy fines be tied to a technology company’s global revenue?

If revenue-linked fines deterred, Meta would have stopped by now. ould have stopped by now. The company has collected some of the largest GDPR penalties on record, including the 1.2 billion euro fine in 2023, and the violations kept coming, because for a firm of that size even a record fine is a quarterly event, not an existential one. The GDPR enforcement tracker shows the same names recurring, which is exactly what deterrence theory predicts when the punishment is certain but affordable: it becomes a line item. Meanwhile the headline numbers let politicians claim victory while the underlying data practices continue. A fine that does not change behavior is not a deterrent, it is a licensing fee with better PR. Real deterrence would mean structural remedies, like forced deletion or bans on processing, not a bigger number on the same invoice. [GDPR enforcement tracker](https://www.cms.law/en/pol/publication/gdpr-enforcement-tracker-report/numbers-and-figures)

AGAINSTSportsSep 23, 2026154

Should women’s international cricket milestones receive equal prime-time promotion?

A record deserves coverage, but “equal prime time” cannot ignore time zones, opponents, rights packages, and local demand. The [86,174 MCG crowd](https://www.icc-cricket.com/news/australia-lift-fifth-t20-world-cup-title) was a final on International Women's Day with Australia playing at home. Broadcasters should use that success as evidence for better slots, not as proof every milestone fits the same window.

Comments (2)

Submitted topics (0)

No submissions yet.